Most siding damage on a Philadelphia house, such as a few panels blown loose in a storm or a crack from a hard knock, is a section repair: the damaged vinyl panels unlock, come off and get replaced without touching the rest of the wall. Replacing the wall makes sense when the problem is behind the siding (wet or soft sheathing, no water barrier, missing flashing), when many panels are brittle or wavy, or when nothing matches. In the city, a small repair is generally maintenance, replacing a wall covering goes through an L&I "EZ" permit, and historic properties need Historical Commission approval first. In November, don't leave a bare spot open into the winter: water behind siding does the real damage.
Where siding shows up on a Philadelphia house
The fronts of most rowhomes are brick or stone, but siding is common elsewhere. The City Planning Commission's Philadelphia Rowhouse Manual notes that kitchen and bathroom additions at the back of rowhouses were often built cheaply, usually as wood framing with wood siding. The manual also shows aluminum siding on bay windows and a cornice wrapped in vertical aluminum siding. In the suburbs, whole houses are often sided.
The manual takes a clear position on refacing masonry: because vinyl and aluminum weren't used originally, it says siding "is usually detrimental to a rowhouse," and that covering a masonry wall with any material requires a building permit and an inspection to make sure the wall is structurally sound. Siding over a brick wall is a bigger project than fixing siding you already have.
A Philadelphia-specific case: if the house next door is demolished, your party wall can end up exposed. L&I's Party Wall Protection standard covers finishing walls exposed during demolition, requires the wall covering within 60 days after the wall is exposed, and says the demolition permit's final inspection won't pass until the covering is installed and has passed L&I inspection. If your wall was left bare, raise it with whoever pulled the demolition permit and with L&I through 311.
How vinyl siding is supposed to work
The installation manual published by the industry's trade association, the Polymeric Exterior Products Association, says:
- Vinyl siding can expand and contract ½ inch or more over a 12½-foot length with normal seasonal temperature changes.
- It should be installed over a continuous water-resistive barrier "to stop the intrusion of incidental water," with flashing integrated around openings, corners and wall-roof intersections.
Its horizontal siding chapter adds the fastening rules: nails go in the center of the nailing slots, with about 1/32 inch (the thickness of a dime) between the nail head and the siding, and the head should not be driven tight. Panels stop 1/4 inch short of corner posts and channels, and that gap grows to 3/8 inch when installing below 40°F.
The trade magazine JLC's builder's guide to vinyl siding adds that, like other siding, vinyl lets some water get behind it, especially in wind-driven rain. The siding is the first layer, not the waterproof one, so what happened to the felt, housewrap and wood behind a panel often matters more than the panel.
Reading the damage: a walk-around
Walk around in daylight and check upper walls from the yard or alley with binoculars, not from a ladder.
- Loose or missing panels. Wind gets under a panel that has unlocked from the one below it. L&I's wall covering standard calls for vinyl siding fasteners that go into the framing, no more than 16 inches apart on horizontal siding unless the manufacturer says otherwise, so panels that keep coming off are worth a look at how they were nailed.
- Cracks and holes. JLC notes that in intense cold vinyl becomes brittle enough to shatter from an icy snowball. Look closely near the ground and anywhere things get bumped, like next to the trash cans; a crack lets water straight in.
- Waves and buckling. A panel that bows out between nails often can't move the way the manual intends, for example because it was nailed tight or butted against a corner or channel without a gap. Replacing just that panel won't help if the next one is nailed the same way.
- Around windows, doors and the roof line of a rear addition. Where the addition's roof meets the main wall, and above each window, water is supposed to be turned out by flashing. Gaps here can cause the stains described in our ceiling water stain guide.
- Behind a missing panel. If you can see the wall, look at the barrier. Torn felt or housewrap, dark or soft wood, or wood that dents under a thumb means the repair is bigger than one panel.
- Inside. Peeling paint, damp plaster or a musty smell on the inside of a sided wall points to water already getting through.
Repair a section or replace the wall?
When a section repair is enough
The manual's repair procedure is short: slip a zip lock (unlocking) tool behind the bottom of the panel above the damaged one and unzip it, bend the upper panel out gently, pull the nails from the damaged panel, lock the new panel on and nail it, then zip the upper panel back over the new one's lock.
That works well when the damage is limited to a few panels, the barrier and wood behind them are sound, and you can get panels in the same profile and color. Matching is the hard part. JLC notes that old siding may have faded, so a new panel can stand out, and suggests a practical trick: take weathered panels from a spot nobody sees and use them on the visible wall, then put the new panels in the hidden spot. Check the basement too; leftover panels from the original job are the best match you'll find.
When replacement makes more sense
- Water damage behind the siding is spread over a wide area, or there is no water-resistive barrier at all.
- Many panels are cracked, chalky or brittle, or buckled across the whole wall.
- You can't find a match and the patch would be on a wall you look at every day.
- Flashing at the windows or the roof line is missing, and fixing it means taking the siding off anyway.
Replacement is also the time to have the wall done to the current standard: a continuous water barrier, flashing at every opening and intersection, and corrosion-resistant fasteners, as L&I's Exterior Wall Coverings standard requires.
Older houses: lead paint and asbestos under the siding
On a house built before 1978, the siding may be nailed over old painted wood. EPA's RRP rule questions page covers that case for aluminum siding: if removing it disturbs more than 20 square feet of the old paint underneath, the federal lead-safe rule applies and the work area must be contained. The rule covers paid work, so the contractor's firm should be EPA lead-safe certified. Our lead paint guide explains what that means on the job.
EPA's asbestos overview lists roofing and siding shingles among the places asbestos is found in homes. If your house has stiff, flat, cement-like shingles rather than vinyl, metal or wood, don't saw, drill or break them before a sample is tested. In Philadelphia, Air Management Services requires an asbestos abatement permit, which only a licensed asbestos abatement contractor can get, before removing 40 linear feet or 80 square feet of asbestos or more, and a notification at least 24 hours ahead for smaller amounts. The City's asbestos information line is (215) 685-7576.
Permits: what the City and the suburbs require
In Philadelphia. L&I's building permit page says repairs related to regular maintenance often don't need a permit, as long as the property isn't historic. Replacing the wall covering is a different matter: L&I lists "wall covering replacement" among its permits without plans (EZ permits). The Exterior Wall Coverings standard covers vinyl, fiber cement, wood, stucco and masonry veneer. Ask anyone quoting a re-side who pulls that permit.
Two things change the picture:
- Historic properties. The EZ process doesn't apply to buildings on the Philadelphia Register without prior approval from the Historical Commission, and L&I won't accept the application without it. See our historic district guide.
- Special areas. The same standard says facade alterations in several areas, including the Queens Village, Powelton Village and Wissahickon conservation overlays, need City Planning Commission approval.
In Bucks and Montgomery counties. The Pennsylvania Uniform Construction Code, under 34 Pa. Code § 403.1(b)(10), doesn't apply to installing aluminum or vinyl siding on an existing house, except where a local ordinance requires it, and some townships and boroughs do. Call your municipal code office before work starts, and ask whether a local historic district reviews exterior changes.
Whoever does the work, check their Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor registration first; our contractor checklist shows how.
Before winter: what to do now
- Close up bare spots. A missing panel over intact housewrap can wait for the right part; torn barrier or exposed wood should be covered until the repair.
- Don't nail loose panels tight. Nails driven through a flapping panel pin the vinyl so it can't move, and it can buckle or crack when the temperature swings.
- Ask about cold-weather work. Siding can go up in the cold, but vinyl gets brittle in hard cold and the gaps at the trim should be wider (3/8 inch below 40°F, per the installation manual).
- Photograph storm damage close up and from a distance, with the date, before anything is removed, and check your homeowners policy before you agree to a full replacement.
When to call a pro
Call a siding contractor when:
- the damage is above the first floor, or the only place for a ladder is a neighbor's yard or a narrow walkway;
- the wall behind the siding is wet, soft or stained inside;
- more than a few panels are damaged, or you can't find a match;
- the house was built before 1978, or you see cement-like shingles that may contain asbestos;
- the property is historic, or the plan involves covering masonry;
- your party wall was exposed by a demolition next door.
Checklist: describing the job so you get useful estimates
- Material: vinyl, aluminum, wood, fiber cement, stucco, or "not sure."
- Which wall (front, back, side, rear addition, bay) and which floor.
- Roughly how many panels or how much area, and whether you have leftover panels.
- Photos: one close-up of the damage, one of the whole wall, and one of any stains inside.
- What happened and when, such as a storm on a specific date.
- Access: through the house, from an alley, or only through a neighbor's yard.
- The year the house was built, and whether it's historic.
On HomeKept you can describe the job once, starting from our siding page, and compare up to three estimates from local pros; it's free for homeowners. Clear photos help a contractor judge before the visit whether it's a section repair or a bigger job.
HomeKept is a brand of FalconAI LLC, 331 E Street Rd, Feasterville-Trevose, PA 19053.
HomeKept needs JavaScript. Please enable it and reload the page. ·
HomeKept necesita JavaScript. Actívalo y vuelve a cargar la página. ·
Для работы HomeKept нужен JavaScript. Включите его и обновите страницу.