Repointing (often called tuckpointing) means raking worn mortar out of a brick wall's joints and packing in new mortar. Your wall needs it when the mortar is crumbling, cracked or worn back from the brick face, when bricks are loose, or when the inside of an outside wall shows damp and damaged plaster. On an older Philadelphia house the biggest decision is the mortar itself: it should be softer and more breathable than the brick, which usually means a lime-rich mix, not a hard cement patch. In the city, L&I doesn't require a building permit for masonry pointing, but the Historical Commission reviews it on designated properties, and scaffolding on the sidewalk needs a Streets Department permit. In November, also watch the thermometer: the wall should be between about 40°F and 95°F during the work.
Signs your brick needs repointing
The National Park Service's guide to the subject, Preservation Brief 2: Repointing Mortar Joints in Historic Masonry Buildings, says the decision to repoint usually follows an obvious sign: disintegrating mortar, cracks in the joints, loose bricks or stones, damp walls or damaged plaster. On a rowhome or twin, walk around and look at:
- The joints themselves. Mortar that has worn back from the brick face, or that turns to sand when you scrape it with a screwdriver, has lost its grip.
- Under windowsills, cornices and parapets, and next to downspouts. Water runs and collects in these spots, so the mortar goes first.
- Air conditioners. The City Planning Commission's Philadelphia Rowhouse Manual shows brick damaged by a dripping window unit and advises against cutting holes through solid walls for air conditioners, because the opening lets moisture in.
- Ivy and weep holes. The same manual says to keep vines off the house, because their roots can destroy mortar, and to keep the small weep holes near the base of a brick wall clear so moisture can drain.
- Inside. Peeling paint or crumbling plaster on an outside wall often means water is coming through the masonry.
Fix the water source first
The NPS brief is blunt about this: repointing alone won't solve problems that come from somewhere else, such as leaking roofs or gutters, a building that has settled unevenly, or water wicking up from the ground. If the cause isn't fixed first, it says, "any repointing will have been a waste of time and money."
In a rowhome, look for a gutter or scupper spilling down the back wall, an open parapet cap, or a flat roof leaking at the edge; our flat roof guide covers what to check. Bulging brick, a wall leaning out of line, or cracks that keep coming back can be signs that the building is moving, which is a question for a structural engineer before it is a job for a mason.
Why the mortar matters more than anything else
Most Philadelphia brick came from local makers. The Rowhouse Manual explains that its outer surface is the hardest part, because it was exposed to high heat in firing, while the inside is much softer. Brick is porous: it takes in a little water and dries out again. The manual says mortar needs similar properties so the two expand and contract at the same rate.
The NPS brief sets out the rules a repointing mortar should meet:
- It matches the old mortar in color, texture and the way the joint is finished (tooling).
- It is softer and more vapor-permeable than the brick.
- It is no harder and no less permeable than the historic mortar.
It also warns that it's "a common error" to assume harder, stronger mortar is better. Moisture and dissolved salts should leave the wall through the joints; when the mortar won't let them, they leave through the brick, and salts crystallizing inside it can push its face off. The brief shows a wall where hard portland cement mortar trapped moisture until "water pressure eventually popped the surface off the bricks." The joint is supposed to be the sacrificial part, the piece that wears out and gets replaced, not the brick.
For soft brick, the brief calls a soft, high-lime mortar necessary. It names the high-lime mixes by type: Type O (1 part portland cement, 2 parts lime, 9 parts sand by volume), Type K (1:3:11) and straight lime and sand. Ask any mason which mix they plan to use on your wall, and why, before they open a bag.
How good repointing is done
These points come from the NPS brief unless noted. Use them as questions for any mason.
- Depth. Old mortar should come out to at least 2 to 2½ times the width of the joint, which for most brick means about ½ to 1 inch, plus any loose mortar behind that. The brief says that depth is what gives a good bond and prevents new mortar from popping out.
- Hand tools first. A hammer and chisel is the least damaging way to remove mortar. The brief says power saws on walls with thin joints, like most brick walls, "almost always" chip the brick edges and overcut the vertical joints. The Rowhouse Manual adds that many 19th-century rowhouses have very thin "butter joints" that must be cleared by hand, not sawed out into a wider joint.
- A test panel. Before the whole job, the mason repoints a small area, about 3 feet by 3 feet for brick and preferably not on the front of the house, so you can approve the color, texture and joint profile.
- Not too full. Filling joints flush over the brick edges makes them look wider than they are and leaves a thin edge of mortar that breaks off and lets water in.
- Gentle cleanup. Excess mortar comes off with a natural-bristle or nylon brush, never a metal one. The Rowhouse Manual warns never to sandblast brick or clean it with acid, because that strips the hard outer skin.
- Curing. High-lime mortar shouldn't dry too fast; the brief describes misting the joints and covering the wall with burlap for three days.
- Dust. Grinding out mortar makes respirable crystalline silica dust. OSHA's tuckpointing fact sheet describes the controls: a shroud on the grinder, a vacuum pulling at least 25 cubic feet per minute per inch of blade with a high-efficiency filter, and respirators. Ask how the crew will control dust, and close your windows and your neighbors'.
- Painted brick. On a painted wall in a house built before 1978, raking the joints disturbs old paint; our lead paint guide explains when the federal lead-safe rules apply. The Rowhouse Manual also warns against painting brick with anything that isn't breathable, because trapped water freezes and breaks the brick face.
Done this way, the brief says, repointing is meant to last at least 30 years, and preferably 50 to 100.
Is November too late to repoint?
Not automatically, but the window is closing. The NPS brief says wall temperatures between 40°F and 95°F keep the water in fresh mortar from freezing or evaporating too fast. Late in the fall that depends on the week, and on the nights as well as the days. If you book now, ask how the mason will protect the new joints if the forecast turns cold, and be ready to push a large job to spring.
What shouldn't wait is the water: the Rowhouse Manual explains that water trapped in brick expands when it freezes and breaks the surface. Before winter, clear gutters, reconnect downspouts, stop air conditioner drips and get loose bricks at parapets and chimneys looked at. Our chimney inspection guide covers the chimney.
Permits and approvals in Philadelphia
- Pointing alone. L&I's construction next door FAQ lists masonry pointing among the small projects that don't need a permit.
- Rebuilding or covering a wall. Replacing or altering a masonry facade does need a building permit. L&I's EZ Masonry Facade standard covers one-family homes up to three stories; anything outside it needs plans. The Rowhouse Manual notes that covering a masonry wall with any material, such as stucco or siding, requires a building permit and an inspection.
- Historic properties. If your house is on the Philadelphia Register of Historic Places, on its own or in a historic district, the Historical Commission lists masonry cleaning, painting, pointing and repair among the work it reviews. Contact the staff at preservation@phila.gov before work starts. Our guide to historic district rules explains the process.
- Scaffolding on the sidewalk. Scaffolding, lifts or a dumpster that close a sidewalk or lane need a street closure permit from the Streets Department. Only licensed contractors and businesses can apply, so ask your contractor to pull it.
- In the suburbs. In Bucks and Montgomery counties, permit rules are set by each township or borough. Call yours before scaffolding goes up.
What drives the cost
The NPS brief says plainly that repointing is expensive and time consuming. Instead of a number, here is what moves the price:
- Spot or whole wall. Repointing only the bad areas is usually preferable, but the brief says that if 25 to 50 percent or more of a wall needs it, doing the entire wall may cost less overall.
- Access. The brief calls scaffolding expensive, and suggests scheduling roof, gutter and other exterior work so it all uses the same scaffold.
- Scattered repairs. One foot of pointing in five different spots costs more than five feet in one place.
- Handwork. Removing mortar by hand is labor-intensive, and thin butter joints have to be done that way.
The brief recommends a base price plus unit prices, for example per linear foot of brick pointing, so the cost of more or less work than estimated is clear in advance.
Checklist before you hire
- Photograph the problem areas up close and from across the street, inside and out.
- Find and fix the water source: gutters, downspouts, roof edge, air conditioner.
- Find out whether the house is on the historic register, and if so, contact the Historical Commission staff.
- Ask each mason: which mortar and why, hand tools or grinder, a test panel, dust control, and protection from cold.
- Get the scope in writing: which walls, spot or full repointing, the mortar type, unit prices for extra work, and cleanup.
- Check the contractor, including Pennsylvania Home Improvement Contractor registration.
When to call a pro
The Rowhouse Manual lists re-pointing and masonry cleaning and repair among the projects better left to professionals. A few joints on a low garden wall can be a reasonable first try if you follow the NPS guidance. A street facade, anything you'd need tall ladders or scaffolding to reach, painted or historic brick, loose bricks, or a wall that bulges or keeps cracking calls for an experienced mason, and sometimes a structural engineer first.
On HomeKept you can describe the job once and compare up to three estimates from local concrete and masonry pros in Philadelphia, or in Bucks County and Montgomery County. It's free for homeowners. Add close-up photos of the joints and a photo of the whole wall, say whether the brick is painted and whether the house is in a historic district, and ask every pro the mortar question.
HomeKept is a brand of FalconAI LLC, 331 E Street Rd, Feasterville-Trevose, PA 19053.
HomeKept needs JavaScript. Please enable it and reload the page. ·
HomeKept necesita JavaScript. Actívalo y vuelve a cargar la página. ·
Для работы HomeKept нужен JavaScript. Включите его и обновите страницу.